St. John’s has won the Annapolis Cup 32 out of 40 matches; the Midshipmen have taken the trophy eight times. (See Victories below.)
According to legend, the rivalry began in 1982 when the commandant of the U.S. Naval Academy was speaking with St. John’s freshman Kevin Heyburn and remarked that the Midshipmen could beat the Johnnies in any sport. “What about croquet?” was the Johnnie’s retort. He later proposed the match to a group of Midshipmen in the interest of fostering better relations between the schools.
The Annapolis Cup, which has been housed everywhere from the Little Campus (now Galway Bay) to a storage closet to the front window of 49 West in Annapolis, is now kept by the victors.
The Midshipmen wear crisp, U.S. Croquet Association croquet whites, along with a team tie, varying from year to year. The Johnnie uniform changes every year, revealed only minutes before each match. Past years have included camouflage, tuxedoes, Viking clothing, kilts, and even imitation USNA Crackerjacks. Several Plebes in dress mess uniforms serve the players refreshments.
United States : Both the St. John’s and the Naval Academy teams compete in the United States Croquet Association Collegiate National Championships.
In preparation for the match, both St. John’s and the Naval Academy play the Ginger Cove Croquet Team, from the Ginger Cove retirement community. They have met a few weeks prior to the St. John’s match each year since 1992. The day before the match, the Johnnies have lunch with the Midshipmen at the Academy mess hall, where the Imperial Wicket for the Johnnies formally challenges the Midshipmen to a match. The match opens with music. The St. John’s Freshman Chorus sings and the Naval Academy Trident Brass band plays. The Johnnies emerge in their surprise uniforms. Then, the ceremonial first ball is struck.
Courtesy and good sportsmanship are expected of all players. No players may throw a mallet or hit a ball in protest or anger. No trash talk is allowed.
How the game is played: The game played at the annual match is nine-wicket croquet. A full-size croquet court is a rectangle 100 feet long and 50 feet wide. Nine metal wickets and two wooden stakes are arranged in a double diamond pattern. The object of the game is to advance the balls through the course by hitting them with a mallet, scoring a point for each wicket and stake made in the correct order and direction. The winner is the first side to score 14 wicket points and 2 stake points for each of its balls. For the Annapolis Cup, each side has 12 players divided into two-person teams.
2024 - Johnnies
2023 - Johnnies
2022 - Midshipmen
2019 - Johnnies
2018 - Johnnies
2017 - Johnnies
2016 - Johnnies
2015 - Johnnies
2014 - Midshipmen
2013 - Midshipmen
2012 - Johnnies
2011 - Johnnies
2010 - Johnnies
2009 - Johnnies
2008 - Johnnies
2007 - Johnnies
2006 - Johnnies
2005 - Midshipmen
2004 - Johnnies
2003 - Johnnies
2002 - Johnnies
2001 - Midshipmen
2000 - Johnnies
1999 - Johnnies
1998 - Johnnies
1997 - Johnnies
1996 - Johnnies
1995 - Johnnies
1994 - Johnnies
1993 - Johnnies
1992 - Johnnies
1991 - Midshipmen
1990 - Johnnies
1989 - Johnnies
1988 - Johnnies
1987 - Midshipmen
1986 - Johnnies
1985 - Midshipmen
1984 - Johnnies
1983 - Johnnies